|
| Author |
Date
and source |
Quotes |
|
|
|
| Aaron
Schavey, Policy Analyst, Center for International Trade and
Economics, Heritage Foundation |
27
November 2001
Financial Times |
" The evidence shows that increased trade leads to increased
economic growth, which raises labour and environmental standards.
For example, a Brookings Institution study found that the
incidence of child labour declines dramatically as per capita
income rises. Similarly, a recent study by the Heritage Foundation
found that countries that are more open to trade tend to maintain
higher environmental standards. Imposing labour and environmental
standards on developing countries will only deter the most
effective means of raising labour and environmental standards
around the world: increasing growth through increased
trade" |
| Chief
International Trade Center Market Analysis Section, Friedrich von Kirchbach |
3
August 2001
Interview in the International Trade Forum Magazine
|
" The implications from our study are quite clear: exporters
from the 49 least developed countries (LDCs) are significantly
more exposed to ETBs than those from any other group. Though only
half of the LDC exports consist of products potentially affected
by ETBs, among these products some 40% are directly affected,
compared to less than 20% for developing, transition and developed
countries. These poorest countries of the poor may have to face
even tougher hurdles in the future as a result of growing
environmental concern worldwide. This is especially the case for
agricultural products that are among the most exported products by
LDCs."
Link to the full Interview |
| Chief
International Trade Center Market Analysis Section, Friedrich von Kirchbach
|
3
August 2001
Interview in the International Trade Forum Magazine
|
" As you know, WTO rules clearly permit countries to put up
trade barriers for environmental reasons. The questions we tried
to answer are: how widely are such sanctions applied, for what
products, and what are their effects? Of 4,917 products we
examined in world trade, we found only 1,171 that do not face any
environmentally-related trade barriers (ETBs). The 3,746 other
products — that do face barriers in at least one importing
country — accounted for 88% of world merchandise trade (i.e. not
including services) in 1999. You could say that the vast majority
of international trade consists of products potentially affected
by ETBs." |
| World
Bank Vice President, Ian Johnson |
23
July 2001
World Bank Press Release |
" More than ever before, trade and the
rules of the trading system intersect with a broad array of other policies and issues-from investment
and competition policy, to environmental, developmental, health, and
labor standards. These often seem to be a world away from 'traditional'
trade concerns as tariffs and quotas." |
| WTO
Director-General, Mike Moore |
6
July 2001
Speech at the WTO Symposium on Issues confronting the
World Trading System |
" For example, there is no powerful, funded,
global environmental agency. There should be. Heavy, fresh and
creative thinking must be done about the roles, functions,
jurisdictions, obligations, management and mandates of all
international institutions and how we deliver our services. This
is where those not captured by process and bureaucracy can help
the debate. I would welcome your views." |
| The
Globe and Mail |
1
March 2001
The Globe and Mail |
" The WTO puts no restrictions on the power to create or
enforce such laws (environmental laws). In fact, its basic charter
says member countries can take any trade measures they like to
"protect human, animal or plant health". All the WTO
says is that members should not use trade as a weapon when other
issues, such as the environment are at stake."
|
| President
and Chairman of Soros Fund Mangement, George Soros |
5
September 2000
Speech at the State of the World Forum 2000
|
" From the point of view of
international law, the World Trade Organization is perhaps
the most advanced of our international institutions because
it has binding judicial power. The NGOs that protested in
Seattle did have a valid point about the WTO: its rules pay
no attention whatsoever to important issues like the
protection of the environment or labor standards. But the
solution to this problem is not to destroy the WTO but to
establish similarly binding rules regarding these issues.
"
|
| Former
US Trade Representative, Ambassador Charlene Barshefsky |
October
1999
WTO Policy Issues for Parliamentarians
URL
(pdf format, 48 pages,741 KB)
|
" The United States has not released any environmental law or
health or safety law in order to comply with any WTO ruling"
(She explained that where changes to US laws were made, this was
to remove any discrimination in the treatment of foreign companies
and US companies). "
|
| Executive
Director of the UN Environment Programme, Klaus Töpfer |
15
March 1999
Statement
at the WTO High Level Symposium on Trade and Environment
|
" A Joint Effort to Address Trade and
Environment is Needed. This
challenge must be taken up jointly by trade, environment and
development ministries. We can not isolate trade or environmental
policy from the impacts of international debt, the need to
alleviate poverty, the equitable imperative to transfer technology
or the need to enhance the capacity of developing countries to
face the challenges of sustainable development. It
is Neither Fair Nor Reasonable to Expect the WTO to Shoulder All
the Responsibility. " |
| Former
WTO Director-General, Renato Ruggiero |
15
March 1999
Statement
at the WTO High Level Symposium on Trade and Environment
|
" Trade and environment communities are
not divided over objectives. We both want a strong, rules-based
trading system as well as a strong and effective environmental
system, and we both want the two systems to support one another.
The question is how do we arrive at these objectives. We will not
arrive there through unilateralism, through discriminatory actions
and protectionism, with each nation free to impose its standards
and priorities on the other following its own perceptions of the
problem. On the contrary, we will only arrive at our shared
objectives through consensus, through negotiations, by working
towards a much broader vision of a rules-based international order
where trade and the environment fit together as two key pieces of
a much larger puzzle. " |
| AGREEMENT
ESTABLISHING THE WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION
|
|
" Recognizing that their relations in the field of trade and
economic endeavour should be con-ducted with a view to raising
standards of living, ensuring full employment and a large and
steadily growing volume of real income and effective demand, and
expanding the production of and trade in goods and services, while
allowing for the optimal use of the world's resources in
accordance with the objective of sustainable development, seeking
both to protect and preserve the environment and to enhance the
means for doing so in a manner consistent with their respective
needs and concerns at different levels of economic development. "
|
|
<top> |
|